I packed my heart in a shoebox
Taped it shut wrote"do not open"on the lid
Told my friends I'm done with all that
Now look at what I did
Phone buzzes face-down on the table
And my whole face gives me away
So much for never never again
There I go grinning like a fool for you
Biting my lip in the checkout line
Grinning like a fool a fool for you
I used to roll my eyes at couples
Sharing one umbrella down the block
Now I read your goodnight twice
And leave my ringer on around the clock
Your name pops up while I'm brushing my teeth
And I'm smiling through the foam
So much for never never again
There I go grinning like a fool for you
Biting my lip in the checkout line
Grinning like a fool a fool for you
Somebody find that shoebox
Toss the tape I won't be needing it
I swore up and down I was through
Turns out I was only waiting on you
So much for never never again
There I go grinning like a fool for you
Blushing out loud in the checkout line
Grinning like a fool a fool for you
So much for never
Oh a fool for you