
在手机上保存,获得更好体验
本字幕由TME AI技术生成
There are certain things
That we kind of frame and eeast persses west
And these are false sort of frameworks
I think you go to a new country
And you're a guess
But you don't realize that sometimes
And there's a little bit of aricants
And you go and okay
China should be this way
China should should be this way
China should be this way
I have remember stopping in my tracks
And being like when does this happen
I'm on a subway
And to see a people open up at the biggest censorship
It's all about control
Right
It's all about contcontrol
Hecats is never going to actually make it on air s and all this time i said this whole actually gesucup now we know
But it doesn't now we know
Do i ka a whisky
You brought this to my place a long time
Yeah
I think ii when was this i't's come back from japan
Oh
I think this was a trip
Where i went the snowboarum
Iiii completely i mean
I would see
I could not have stised that bad
There's like you know we finished more than half about half of it
Yeah
I don't
I know
I don't really rebght what it ii tell
Tell it goi
I not tell the bottle
Yeah Well
That's why i bought it
Because this re's somewhere i head on it
That's only reason why what i ve like
And you can actually keep the shoulders like the armor on
And just take the head off
Yeah
To pour it
Yeah Yeah
I mean a lot of thought when into this clearly
And i don't remember it being that expensive or that
That tribe there is like i think it was something along the lines of like a hundred box us or like eighty box us
And i
And i bet t fifty
Fifty of those dollars one into like making it
Yeah
Because this is heavy
This is like happy good is like good materials
Like good quality
It's not like you know show that to the camera
When that this i here
So the summer get on here and honestly
But i hope i'm
I'm not to try niko whisky
We tried a long time ago completely forget
How it is we're going to try again
Today i'll let you know i was try super worsky aged in wood guaranteed by our own experts
Okay
Whatever it's a japanese is gogogogogogoyeah ah ii have tried japanese with ski
Before there is a hubbiki
Right right
What's the other one
What's the other one
Mazaaki
Yah
Mazachi
A lot of my friends
Rave about it
They swear by it
So i tried it
I wasn't like it wasn't bad
But i wasn't like a huge huge fan of it to be honest
It does taste little different
I think still depends on the year and which barrow lh you drink out of
But like i think in general the japanese whiskies that we tried
Because a coucouple times we had been together
Yeah
Um we tried the apt
We tried the yamahaccy y well well
Um i just feel like it has
This has a bit more of a of aa general smoke here ill feel
嗯哼
But just oh
The two smokes are right
That's not spoke ke ill
I'm smoking
Smoking sweet little of about to say that a little nectory for i will right you know what whisky
I still can't really get my young
My head around is covel on taiwan is one
Yeah
I've mean a one
A one all these awards right
It's rated uh like one was like number one best whisky
Or something for that year
Or whatever was i tried it not a huge fend to be honest
It could be completely
Why i don't know
I didn't
I didn't really enjoy the taste
I don't really know why i see it again
I don't really know enough about whiskies
I don't know what i'm talking about when to comes to whsky
But just when i tried it
Oh
It in taste us good like this taste better to
So the cost of this is a hundred twenty five box
I in twenty five yeah for as far as whiskies go that's not cheap
You know you bought it
You bought it retail at a
At the story
At the leink
At the airport
Wow
So even at the airports
So that's not
That's not cheap at all i mean how you just wants to kind sort of show that you know he doesn't skip it doesn't on as whiskies
No
We're just trying to find more information about it
Right now so on ii don't know how i logit this website is
But there's ratings is readings on it
And perfect five star reading um
What's the cycled the wine spot
So much
The wine spot yeah
For a rid was clearly experts
Yeah
It's a naaper valley website dedicated to japanese with he clearly yeknow yeah
Anyway he was just looking up the price okay
Howry you don't buy the cheap stuff
We know well here in shanghai
I saw um a mcaan thirty for
For one yeah
Mcaelan thirty year for sixty five thousand rmb yeah
And 'you got to wonder
If you get that if is even real right
Yeah Yeah
I mean that
You think it's real
But re's always that kind of not in the back
So they have
They have a ten thousand dolllar bottles just waiting for you
Yeah Yeah
Right
Who's keppthem to for you right yeah
So i think we should have some homework
Um we should all we should look at or look up the standards of how to talk about whisky
Right um start to exanding our vocabullittle little bit
So when people say this is very pity
What does that mean
You know it's smilt it taste smoky
So pd is equivalent to stuis rally taste smoky
Yeah
Smoky so i
So i have a uh okay
So i have a slightly different perspective than how we right um um
And you guys know i love using google
Wikipedia
An know and and searching online for resources
Right i met
I met um
I met this entrepreneuguy recently tly um um the way he learns is that
What i ver is trying to learn
He just finds the expert on that
And it's more like a human connection
Yeah feel like like whisky love to get kevin
We could partly just go out with you know what yeah like we should raise the barry and highly because eventually
Obviously ly we taltalabout about we
We want to start getting like expert guests on the show
All all different tyes of subjects and just have discussions
And you know ask ask in questions and just kind of like just nurture our curiosity about different subjects
Right i mean we talk about whisky
All of time we saart every every show in new bottle whisky
Way we should try to get a final real whisky spper in shanghahai
Know we should do next time
You know maybe at the every next time
But when already we should do a whisky tasting on this pardtest let that be great
Yeah
Yeah with an expert
And we just get a bunch of with different whiskies
Will do it or do it with well have just a whole episode
Just a't like just having hahadifferent whiskies with an expert
There
And we can keep bassing the questions
And just learn stuff right
Yeah Yeah
Sounds good
We should do that
But see see living in a place like shanghai
It's in asia
It's pretty
It's a really good hub to meet a lot of different interesting people
I think right after the years we spsphere here right
It's
It's really like that's why i know about living here
Because you get a lot of people whether to transient
Whether they're coming going or their experts
And they're just kind of living here a long term like us right um you get a lot of people from a lot of different walx life coming it out of this
This kind of asian hub that were in right from all over the west
And i will see all over asia
You know
And there's you get that in cities like obviously like new york
Can i like too
But it's feel it's different here
I feel
I feel the network is little more accessible here than it is um you know back in the states
You know like give to it feel
Feel like re's
Oh Know
I'll know it maybe because we've been here for very lot of so long well i think the expect community in general in shanghai as compared unless than in new york
I would say it's more robust here for example being from new york
Um
嗯 I mean
Yeah
We meet people from europe
And whatever but mostly is just from different states yeah
Right so it's still americans or we were some canadians
Whatever but like you know a battering a friend just spattertering british
Whatever but like it's not as like really diverse as in shanghai
We're litnot as you're meaning people from ooloiia
Yeah
From europe
Australian
New zealand
Yeah
You know it's just more robust africa like a lot of africans
Yeah
Lot lot europeans love friends chogacy
A lot of sheload of australians
I just think she's more robust in general
So that might be the reason
Why you feel like it's
It's a different vipe
Yeah that's re's one one one number two
I think you saying that it's a transian city at how it's positive picture
You mean a lot of of of people
But i think it's like in that sense
Yes
But also it's
I think it's so excepbecause
Because you have the negative
Because you know i've been here for what since two thousand
Seven seven so almost most twelve hole suses almost twelve years now and um you know i think one of reasons
Why we're
We're closed because we're 're still ses because we're mean
And know know it's so easy
If we have some friends have left
You know
And even more that could think back
When i first moved here
That ah i thought i was going to close to other
Other people we're
're gone transition
You know
Do you think
Do you think people because as such a transition city
When you meet new people
They kind of like don't even really bother to make an effort to kind of really build a bond with you
Because they know like you know you might believe soon
Soon
Or they might believing soon
You feel that way
I don't
I don't
I feel is interesting right ii would agree with somehow is to starts here
I think you know the first thing is that
When you think about a city lake
You know shanganghai
Probably you know lot people memean ar lilisteners
You know people all around the world have heard of shanghai
Have seen into the news
Have you know um an impression of shanghai
But may not have had a chance to visit a new york and la um
You know it's
It's a bit more conventional
Yeah
Right and so when you go to new york
When you go to la
You're just sort of
嗯
Absorbing the culture and in the atmosphere
But i think in shanghai we're actually contributing here
We're building the culture here a little bit
And of course you have of course there's you know that i mean all of the historical elements of china
But china is changing
And the culture is changing
So i think when i go in new york
I'm kind of just like it's new york
It's static
It's incredible
It's
It's maturiity
It's maturiity
It's there where shanghai it's going through that velovelomenmenstage
And we've been here through that developmental stage helped they know people like everyone here is help shaping that what it is
And at the same time we're shaping shanghai
We are being shaped
So i feel like it's a living sort of evolving kind of place
And we're part of that evolution
Where as i think when we visit new york it's sort of like okay we experience that we leave
And that's it
Yeah Ah
So i think that's the interesting thing about shanghahais
That we're 're growing and involving with it
And we're actually helping to build things like a lot of our friends
They start ted different
You know businesses out here restaurants and all kinds of different things
So we see
You know it's changing before our eyes
I think that's truly interesting
I think
I think that's really true
It's
You know
Never really thought about that way
It's like not only is that shaping us
But we're helping to shape it as well
Because it's a developing city
It has a luxury of being shaping
You know when
When we go to cities
Like
But go back in new york
Or are s angeles or london
Or you know any of the major kind of heritage cities
There are very fully mature
You know they've been been away for centuries
Ies ready right um
And they an what they are well i mean they've been around for centuries
And this just you know thethey've matured already to like a full grown status
Where you know you
You can go back ten years from now and still relatively the same you know mean so much much
Chanchange you know hongkong is another example of those capacities
But in shanghai just like our friends
You know jerry and fill who were was going back
You know know you can gone for two years
You know some less yeah and they come back
They like
Like y're like
Oh my golike
And we don't only notice these changes
Because we're here yeday
But it's changing so rapidly both like with its infrastructure and its culture right so it's going through a developmental phase
That is only going to happen once in history before it becomes like a new york
And it's it is what it is
And the change is can happen
You know really incrementally very slowly
Then after it's mature right so i mean that's definitely really interesting
And i think think that's
It's true
You know one thing i've never really
Never ve never really asked ked guys ys are like really talked about before i kind of know
But not really is like how
How did you guys come to be here in the first place
You know like what brought us all to shanghai
Right like individually like with you eare like what what bght ght you unifirst worst
So i've probably been here
I guess the longest first time i was out here
How many years so far so god d can't even to do the math anymore
I think first time i was out here in two thousand and two spend a little bit of time
And then i moved out here in two thousand and three okay so a wild st days yeah
Wd these days yeah
These these
It's wow
Wild yeast
And you know i don't like
I think when i reflect back
I don't think
I really appreciated it
You know i appreciate it more
Now i came out for work
So there was a project
And they asked everyone in the company
Who speaks you know mandren and with my broken mander
And i've passed that
And
And they send me out here
What were you doing here i was working for tecompany
Yeah No
So they needed someone to kind of come out here
And connect with the teams out here
And can help them watch some near some new tech
But how was your manner or at that time was it like like just possible or was it pretty good
Ready my mandor and back then was terrible
But really he was off
Why i think
I think that's same for all
But i mean it was
I mean his manander is the best all all of us right now yeah
I mean it was terrible
I mean i could barely you know
Communicate you know
But it's all related right right compared to everyone else
I mean i could
You know
I could ii went to chinese school back in the day
So like i all go to chinese
Did you go to chinese school back in the day
I felt
I felds
I felt i play to basketball
Ii ay
I disappoint in back in the day
没有吧
Clclass for kkids so always surwriable um
But you know it was
I was the only one that could even you know
Kind of say how are you
Thank you
You know
And so they send me out
Sorry
Ry know so i mean
I don't
I know this re's no
There was no master plan
There was no sort of like four shadowing of china is going to be
The aster to be
Or shanghahais going to be like really a hot bit of innovation and like across all industries
So what was
What was that like one turning point
When you got here
Where you were like almstay
Or did you even have that kind of thought
We don't like a decision
I goall i'm saying it
It's the place to be right now ii think it was the reverse of that
I think it was people really like how long you're going to stay
And you know my response was always like i don't know probably leave next year okay
You know
And then one thing leads to another
And i think you somehow i was getting integrated into the environment here
And you meet people and you know
And there wasn't any kind of maaster plan
Like i hate to say it what you just kind of like formed the comfort level here
And you just kind of just stuck around
I think when i
When i kind of reflect
And i don't know was a comfort level
I almost think because there were challenges
And there were discomfortable
Uncomfortable things that made me wanna stay
It was almost the opposite
It was like there's something changing
It's always different
I'm really uncomfortable
There's a million things to complain about
And yet at the same time
I don't want to be anywhere else you know
It's i completely tely undereland
Because when people
嗯
You know one of the reasons
One of things
I always say is when people like um
Because obviously there are a lot of things to complain about living in china
In general right
Coming from the west
Right
There's a lot of things
Things
There's a lot of conveniences
Here there's a lot little things
Right
Uh that kind of review you the wrong way um
But what i always say what people is the kind of shanghai is rough around the edges
But those kind of like the roughness around those edges are kind of what gives it its charm
You don't mean
Like you're not
Not going to experience these things really anywhere else in the states right or in a lot of the kind of more developed western world i guess
But it's kind of these things that really give it its time is especially back in the days specihe in early two thousands right when it was like really the wildwde east those are of things that we miss now
And we we miss having that kind of culture around you know mean uh i know what i'm living here
It's not
Shanghai is not nearly as fun as it was
You know i got here no night right
And even then it's like compared now ten years it's not
As it's not
It's a huge shift completely different lifestyle
And i think the charm is that it's easy to back home
That in the us to take things for granted
And things are at a very comfortable sort of level
And the things that make you uncomfortable here um they change
And so it is really really rouer on the edges
But what's really really fascinating as that there might be a hundred things that are roufer on the edges
And then one day you wake up
You go on the street
And you see something
And someone decided that they wanted to change something and make it better
And that one thing gives you surprise into light wheas
If you were surrounded by all that at back home
You wldn't even notice you take it
You totally take a regreant
So it's almost like those those sort of subtle hardships
That you see every day they appcitice
You appciciate when something different happens
When one decidecides want
Want to make this better
And i think over time i saw that the energy in the city
And what people wanted to do
Wanted to make things better
And they wanted to change
And people are open minded
And people who come here
And i think that's why we bond wheas you know you might meet people
You know when other cities you may not have those connections
As i actually think it's easier to make a connection here
Because people who come here
They wouldn't have come here
If they w't 't open minhere
They wouldn't come here
If they you know i think there's something else so let me ask you
This because out of the three of us
You came to shanghai
The earliest you've been you're the longest
What would you say
If you had to choose one thing
What would you say was kind of like a single biggest change between when you first guy here and now um so i'll name a couple of things
That i think we can all acknowledge have changed
So the hardware of the city
The just the infrastructure has changed
When i riand
When i arrived
You know i can't remember
Exactly there's probably i'm guessing two subway lines
Then now there's almost twenty
And it chris crosses the city
And sort of now public trtrsportation here
So so so
That's
That's obvivious change
But
But don't think it's
It's bibigest change
Another obvious changes that you know the the skyline of the city
You know the number of buildings
I think you know one third of the worldskskscripers at one point where all on shanhai
So as far as you can go out on any line
It's
It looks the same
It looks like probably the most modern city
Meroparo
When i arririve is probably two places you could get on shanghai 啊
And now you can get better burgers here than probably anywhere else in the world to me
That could be one of the biggest changes of all it's just
Just the the ththb b you know the food and beverage seen here alalno has changed
And there are so many things that if we really kind of reflect it um you know you could all this down that has changed
Those are the the biggest changes
The biggest change for me
And this is just you know
I think it's by by far the biggest change is the mindset of people here
And so you know when i arrived it sort ort how you would expect china a place like china
You know deep in asia to be
And you know
After you know that time
Time is lapsed
The biggest changes been the people
The people are you know
Um the super open minded
Um they embrace ideas faster than anyone else
Um they're innovating
You know i rember
When i arrived
I wouldn't say that people here were the most polite
Ite the world
World
Now some of the most polite people who whold are here
And so i think the people aspect is really
What surprised me the most is like how quickly people can change
How quickly they influence of you know social media
The influence of like international culture has been able to come in kind of mix
And so now i think it's fascinating that you see innovation coming out of china
That is sort of a blend you know
And it's i think for so many years
We we
We saw a lot of sort of imitation
But now i think there's like incredible ideas coming
So it's really the the the energy level and sort of like the the overall um changing perspective addikest the biggest chasay
Socially and culturally
Yeah
It's specisoluly
Yeah
You know it's funny
Say say because i agree
I actually agree with that
With that analysis
But it's funny
Because you have a lot of people saying that you know shanghai is developing so quick uh hardware wise right
Infrastructurally that you know the cultures is having trouble and keeping up with the
With the pace of development right
Socially people are having trouble
Keeping up
But i think i don't
I don't
I don't know you find that case
I think outside side shanghai yes
But in shanghai
I think
I think it's keeping up
If not
Maybe even faster than it is changing
You know yeah
I just just think
Think it's changed all yeah
The minds go with what you're saying because iii clearly remember i've been used two
Two thousand
Seven in like two thousand ten or eleven
I remember like taking the subway and already the changes
I mean obviously skyscraper is all the stuff and to the tent
And i live in already big changes right
And i remember that time
That was a big topic
Was the hardware is changing
It's the the software keep up
But the software not yeah
You still have these spoltware and all the bly and all the stuff right
The the
The service was bad still and stufact that but lelast for the couple ple years
Like let's say the past couple years
But i remember stop being in my tracks
And being like when did this happen
I'm on the subway and to see if people open up
To let people get off the train
And before it was like
Like running back
Like you know
Like charging in yeah
Of course
You still get that once in a while
But and three point
But
But it's
It's like
Or
Or it's like
Oh I'm not
I mean once in a while
I'will happened
But in general people are waiting now
And i don't know when that happened
But it has happened
You know and even driving before it was like people cuuning one off off
And now i'm
I'm staying in the car
And i'm not going to throw up
And like uh it's still pretty bad
Sometimes
Sometimes
Here here
Years
Years ago
You want to shit
Here five years ago
In five years
The mentality of a whole city has changed that's incredible right
And i think it's
It's just onto get
Get I had
I had a very similar tear shed moment
And this was an i''re like me
Me like year and half two years ago
Pretty recently actually like two years ago
Uh
Uh you know pream much along the lines what you send
And for me that moment was
Uh i was
You know in the subway or i had got now the subway
Or were getting out
You know you take
Take esclators up
And for the first time in my experience in shanghai
I saw everyone who was standing on esclator lying up to the right
And there was an open passage to the left for people who want to walk up to escalators right
And i don't most
I really almost shit tehere
I'm like
I'm like i'm so proud
I was so proud
Because i've never seen that
And shhhabefore before
Before everyone's just standing everywhere like they know they have no regard for anyone once ce i pass
And they know how that that concept right
So first time
I saw a lly everyone line up up with the conthe right and people wall a walking
Walk on the left
And i was just so i got so proud
And yeah
Yeah
That's ah
Yeah
But going back to can software keep up with the hardware
I feel like it has caught up
And i feel like the hardware is still getting developed
But not as quickly as it used to be
It's slow down a bit
So that's why it feels like a software has caught up a bit
You know
I think and software being the mentaliof
The people
And
And this
This is really interesting
So i'll share
You know some of the feelings i had i'll share two things
So one of the things is about i used to travel around asia
Quite a bit
You know
So you know
I've be in korea
I've be in japan
Taiwan
Singapore
Phalalaysium
India
Philippines
In sarah
And i distinctly remember there was a hierarchy
There was a hierarchy
In terms of your expectations of what that experience would look like so um about about ten years oo had fily in india
I was in india
Probably you know ten fifteen
Twenty times that year
And so diwas sort of like of course there's a certain trime and all of these countries
But in terms of the level of service
The level of infrastructure
Going from china to india
That was definitely a difference
And so when i come back to china
There would be a feeling of relief
That things would work in the same way at the same time
When i go back home every year
So i try to get back once you're twice a year back to the states
There would be a sense of relief
Because the infrastructure just everything
The familiarity and how everything worked was so much more seen less in the us
This was ten years ago
Now fast forward
Now um probably the last two or three years right coinciiting with sort of the party of the season on the subway
Um you know when i go back to the us and come back
And go back in forth
I don't experience that that sort of culture shock or reverse culture shock as much
There's much more parody and in fact
I almost feel like the service andhere china is it's better
Better better
And many ways
And many ways
You know it's interesting
Because like taiwan
Japan
These used to be a sort of gogoststandbecause these are the places
You want to go
These are the places
Where you
You be like i really want a vacation in these places
Because everything is
Is so
And i don't know when it was
But at some point
I feel like we are really blessed
And we're really lucky
That you know china not just shanghai
I travelled all cross now my
My role or takes kes all around china
And i just i love experiencing the way
Things have changing each of these cities in their own individual way
And it's incredible
Right like you feel that human connection
I feel like we came in with these western
You know
I think you go to a new country
And you're a guest
But you don't realize that sometimes
And there's a little bit of of rogants
And you go and like okay
China should be this way
China should be this way
China should be this way
China has had five thousand years of history
It's know
It's know
It's been china for a long time yeknow
It's have a expeexpetations
And maybe the're not fair
We try to compare
Yeah
Because we try comare it to you know western those come from a complete tive in history
You know we bring in a lot of baggage
We bring a lot of expectations
Biois ys and biases
I was say that one of the things
I enjoy ed most
And if
If i had to say why am i still in china
It's the human connection
Which i never thought you know
I never thought that
This was something that would kind of keep me here um
It's the human connection
It's kind of seeing like how people are growing and changing and learning
So the learning agility of people in china is probably better than anywhere else in the world
It's incredible
It is absolutely phenomenal
The learning agilility
The ability to adapt t ability
Adadapt
Yeah No
It's funny
When you
When you brought up kind of
When you both brought up something you both mention was like kind of
Like service right and how we always side like you know china used to
And it there's large truth
And he start ted stigma like in a really bad service or now and distinccompaare to like west right but now to whole different bar game
And it brings me
It's an observation that i've made in in terms
Um
You know just when it es es commcommon service
When you go
Go to restaurant
Restaurant or something that um the tipping culture right so in the west
We come from a tipping culture
But in asia
It's a non tipping culture right no matter where you go in asia
It's
It's as a whole
It's not a tipping
You can
You can choose it tip at certain places
But as a on a whole
You're not required
It's a tipped
Like
Like you are in the states right
Yeah
You're
And so america knows southeast asia
China
Korea
Taiwanan
Japan
It's not a dipiculture
And it's weird
Because you actually get better service in these regions right all these kind of countries besides china historically that we listed are were all known for their great service right
Thailand right
Korea
Japan
Tawo an these are all places are known for excelltservice service singapore right um
Yeah
It's they didn't
They never adopted a tipping culture where as in the west
Especially in the states
It's huge on tipping
It's
It's very reliant on tips
And you know right now the game indicully start at twenty percent right beremimum
Twenty percent right
Which is infiorating
It's infiorating that of the services terrible
You give fifteen percent
Yeah
And of the services growing up
Growing up in the stage
It ah to be fifteen percent was like what
What you give
Give up great service
Service you know in
And now now like if you're go to new york
I like manhattan
Like twenty percent like very ar minimal
Like you give anything thing lower the twenty perent ent
They'll give you a love with the fuck
You know
And you know what's most inferorating to me
Our taxes do you have to tip for taxi
I don't know what the tip is for okay a service at a week at a sponthethey're working hard
They're finding good service
I tip them
I think great
I'll tell you if you give to your service
I'll you no no problem for a taxi
I don't know what i'm tipping for it
Because i'm paying you would fair to get me from point a to point b
That's what the fair is for what am i tipping you for and in new york
You have to tip a taxes
Dary twenty percent basically on top p of the fair for what you know so are you
I am getting on track
But the whole point is you know like a break
Like both have only reason
Why i bring the subice
Because it reminds me of a debate
I used to have an observation at it
Because i will live
We both live on both sides of defence right both of the western united states in particular
And we both spent a lot of time living in asia and travling around asia
And the differences i see is i
You know
I don't think the pping system really works out well right because if you look at all the places with really the best service in terms of on a whole region wise
I'm not not talking in vividual restaurants
I'm doesn't they know know regigithey're all like usually in asia the best services
So that could be something do with i culturally
Maybe people's mds say here are just more like service oriented
But it could be be lowed to do with you know it the fact
That they don't have the thing to work for the typ outknow because it's kind of kind of intuide
If you think tipping would make the service better
But then you look at the actual facts and in your observations
And it's not necessary the case
It's
It's like i think it's
It's
It's culture
Because even something as simple
I'm
I'm speaking in particular to china
Um you know coming from america
We are program to say thank you for everything
Yeah ii find myself saying it way too much
Right the thanks thank she
She ah you know like that
And then like a common response for from service people or
Or anybody
Really is like why you're thinking me
This is what i'm supposed to do
Like this is my job description
Like i am doing my job
My job is to serve you to the up to the best of my bill
You know know lelet's say uh awairight
My job is to get you
Your food explaplathe food you know whatever ver i'm you the bill
You know clear the table that's my job you know
And i'm going to do it to the best of my bill
So why are ththinking you
You know it's like so do you think is better
Because right there's two schools of a ght right right one is you know the more you say thank you the more pleasant
You might seem on a daily basis and in a case by case basis to people more frequently
But on the other side is that like well maybe in the west
You know
Because we say thank you so willingllly and for every little thing
Everything
Thank thank thank thank
You don't
Don't think about it
It comes out instinctially as a like just a reaction
I'll say thank you without even knowing i said thank you and i mean so i thank you
Almost kind of loses its me yeah right so in china here i feel weird because allowed things i want to say thank you
It and i'll feel like i'm being rude by not same thank you
But that's kind of the norm here right
But i think when people actually do say thank you here
Especially the locals they really mean
They mean it because like you really did something from them
And they like thank you
You know i mean
Or as it's not just comba really nearly kind of like throwing out thank you is after right i know no it retains maybe more more more meeting
That i think this overall topic that were kind of exploring of just living here and coming having a western background
It's like i think one thing stcertain to realize is that we've changed living here
You know
Just like you mentioned before
And you first came here
You came with baggage
You came with you know china needs to be like this or you
You can't be doing things like that you know it's said aa set tter
But like we've been here for over ten years all of us
And we realize that
That not not so black away you know
And we challenge our own we of thinking you know like things that we are you know program to be like thank you
All the time you
You start ted question is it necessary to say thank you for everything yeknow
Or do you say say thank you
Do you really mean it
Yeah
You know even like the idea of relationships right um in the west
I love you right is a very comment like you know
Always telling youyou're significant other i love you
I love i love you
And one thing that i got with
With vive is she's like
Why do you always have to say it
It's like there's no meaning to it
And i'm like you're right
Maybe
Maybe you maybe you're right
And it's like all of and like randomly
There's once in a while moments come out
It's like wow
Like that impact becomes a lot more
And then it just in general
That's how it is right here um just when you're saying something
If you're doing something
There's meaning behind them which is interesting
Yeah
I take on this is that
And i thought about this is that
You know there is that reflex to say thank you
She's in i
You know
I'm noticed that reflects and others as well
But my reflection is that you know ii find the value in being at pause in the moment to say it and so for me it's not just
It's no longer just to reflex
It's something that i try to be consistent about and the intentionality of being consistent and you know
Saying thank you because throughout the day there are lots a lot
I think we're not actually as grateful as we need to be
There re's so many things that happen throughout the day that would not be possible without others
And if you really reflect on your life
Anywhere that's true
It's really just a lack of awareness
And once you have that awareness
And you realize that everyone you're interacting with this a human being
That is just
Has just as many feelings and sort of um intentions as you do
And that thank you takes on different
Different being so i'm very big beliebeliein and thank um it makes a big impact on me
When people say thank you
But i also try to be speciice
Specific
And say i'm thank you for doing this
Thank you for this
I work is part of you know
And my sort of dayjob our culture is very much about thank you in recognition um
And then going back to the tipping
I think that if we create a culture
Where tipping is purely a financial incentive
Then the result ultimately will be that you only get good service and probably not even really humanly impactful service
When you tip well um and so um you know i kind of lean towards
嗯
You know making sure that people get that positive recognition and that gratitude emotionally
And then that the economic model of the service provider and the relationship between the service provider and that individual is a healthy enough one
So i'm willing to pay more
But i'd rather it be constructed and integrated
So the 嗯
Price of the overall service
Yeah
I rather pay more at the restaurant
And rather pay more at the hotel
And then rather that organization take care of its employees and do the great cultures
Yethink that's the thing
I think a lot of that has to do um
Whether it's a tipping culture or system or not has to do the hiring right
So i think in the west is people know um
You know if you come in
And you applying for a job as a waiter or any service position
And they know that your job is heavily
Predominantly with lie on the tips you get to make an income
They think think the're going aa
Y're going na less
Less of a like y're going to scrutinize less in terms of
Oh
Your peoplekilales o're because
Because like
Like oh
Because
You know whether 're going to ether niit's going to be based on and aci
How you're going
Going be
Be earning tips
So that's on you almost
So they put that on you almost
Because like the tips are that that's on you
And i mean
I'm going an pay you a base salary
Like your free agent exactly i mean pay you a based salary
But however well you perform that
That's you because
Because you're going to be motivated to make those tips
I they feel less of to kind of or less of a need to be like really kind of run through people
And how well they would fit for that position well as here
Because there isn't a tipping culture
I think the employers are you going to take a lot more seriously that people they hire for these serpositions
Because they
They know it's not a typiculture ture
They know they have to hire someone who kind of really fit the bill
Who really would be
You know funny
Or
Or you know would be
If wewere talking about waiters would really fit the bill to be a quit waiter at their particular establishment
So they would take the employer would take a lot more seriously the hiring process or as in the west maybe for service positions they take a little less seriously
Because they know you're going to have
You're going
Going be
Be most momovvated make tips
Ps
So they've kind of put that responsibility on new versus
Shldoing that responsibility from the for themselves
And i mean
Oh
I don't know
I think there's
I mean just a interview process and general for restaurants
Um
I mean i used to wait tables back in new york
I mean there's
There's still looking for the repersonality for the type of restaurant at you have i mean i've worked at a very fancy restaurant before
And i mean yes
Like you have a standard
You have to look look a certain way
And you have to talk a certain way
And in otherwise
There's matter what kind of experience
You have
You know
Yeah
Ii think there is
But i think it's more cosmetic in the west
Like he said they didn't look a certain way you have to you come across ss cercertain way i ss ss
Oh
Know i think here it's
It's less cosmetic
And it's more just about like you know your actual performance right and the st is more about
I think just based on your experience in your reservate
When i reflect on this particular question
I thought about this before
And you know um
Then i know obviously we can't say for sure
But ii do you know i'm a sticklar for customer service
So i probably the tough as customer
So it's something that i'm am pasonate about
And i say okay
Well
What's changed in the last couple of years
Like why has service gent
Why is it gone from like one of the worst places
And where why is it gone from a place
Where i'm literally furious one a daily basis
Right i mean
You used think think think fist of furury right um
And then now i'm kind of like i mean
It's like come by
I like you know every single day
And i think about
And i think like there's a couple of things
Ii think number one i work with a lot of you know people who work born in the nineties
Or you know eighties nineties
And i think that they've had more of a chance to experience the very services of products that they may be offering
And i think there was a point in you know ten fifteen years ago
Where we were trying to experience something that wasn't common in china
That was a western and sort of type of experience
And these things have been ubiquous diah and china is grown and change and developp
So that there are incredible experiences in
In china
The
The kids that have grown up in the last twenty thirty years
Are experiencing these things
They traveling that getting out of the country they are experiencing so when then they are on the other end of it trying to offer these types of services
There is a certain level of empathy and understanding they've tried the food they've ed ed the whatever is the international crazine
Which ten fifteen years ago they hadn't experience
So i think there is that sort of connection
There and i think the second piece is that you are talking about the biggest economy in the world
It's brutal competitive
It is actually bruly competitive
And if you don't raise the bar ar step up your gayou're not going to be in business
And so i think those two factors
I think you know sort of the first one is unique to china in a way
Just it's like where it is in terms of how it's grown
Because no sort of no country
The size of china has had such accelererated growth in development
And such a shperiiof time
But the second is just i think it's suggest a market dynamic
Any country eventually you get a point
Where there re's a lot of competition
Um
And you have to deliver at that level
You know know
So i think those are two ably that i see that have positively impacted what we experience on a
On a data basis
Um
对对对
And you know the the
The irirpiece is then couple with how you manage people
And if you look at like the companies like dd
And
And you know um other companies they're actually innovative in their management practices is now so where is ten twenty years ago
Where looking to the west for their management practices
Chinese leading the world
So uh it's is again as the innovation pieces
Now it's interesting how bipolar
It is 嗯
Ten fifteen years ago
Where 're like china is so far behind there's so much the stigma
And now it's like they can't do anything wrong anymore
So it is incredible
That such a massive place of people can change so quickly
Or i think
I think that goes back
Ii mean to icyou off back
And that that goes back to what you said about competition
Because now more than ever before in china 's history
All the china needs to compete on an international stage
Because all the companies here
All the major companies here coming up
Need to really compete in the brutal international market right
So the reason
Why i think one of the main drivers
I think why allow these chinese companies are becoming really kind of innovative in terms of like um management acaces es you know these people
People management
You know personal is that
Because they had a crop of people that were not kind of up to stuff in that regard
They had to really take drastic measures to find innoinnovative
Innovative ways to kind of get people to work well to to
To start
Thinking correctly
You it's in benefit of the company right
So it was kind of like a forest
Because through the market competition
They were forced to make these big changes
They had to find ininvvative ways
Because they couldn't keep going on the way they were
Because they didn't have the kind of right material to work with back
Then
So they had to figure out away
How do we give people who are some qualified in many aspects to be qualified or to to work
You know in benefit of our company
So they had to find out
They had to think outside the box
So to speak to find to kind of force
Because they have to underunder pressure of competing internationally now you know
Yeah
I think another way to look at it is the just
There was a lack of baggage
And in a way i mean there are starting from scratch
There was an interesting question posed to the
The kitfhou is
Is you know was the formal like microsoft
An apple
Microsoft
Google executive
Um led
Microsoft led google
Chchina
Right is quite sort of you know well known figure and the high tech world
And the question was posed to him
Recently
And it was like who's going to win the battle of ai arficial intelligence
I is it going to be the us
And you're going to be china
You know
And i think his answer was interesting
His answer was that he felt china was going to win
Not necessarily
Because it had you know more talented people
More innovative better systems
You know i mean you could argue that the us has better systems
Better methodologies
But there's just i'm much more dense concentrated sort of population of people that can compete
And it's the competition
It's the you know the
The drive the competition energy
And so when you have more experiexperiments happening
Resusut t of scicientific experiments are going to leave you too success
And just by the sheer mass are what's happening in china
He believe that ai would eventually here surpass what's in the us
Even though the methodologies arguably in the usi don't see that now i think in many ways you know not necessarily pretained to ai
But in many ways that's already happening
No
And it's not just aiai is this sort of one category
Yeah
There can be anything that we don't know what the future looks like well just think about the convenience of lifestyle here in shanghai
Verversises you know even back in new york
Right right
So so what let me i see this justin
What do you carry now when you leave the house
What do you have about my person
Yeah Yeah
Would you have like i know you just have a man purse
But you kind of got i don't have a mepurse
How it that was how is sorry that's mean no me so i was yll carry my keys uh my phone
Of course um the transit card okay um so you still this still can't of wee darages
That's weird d don't
Don't uh applet me let me answers
Let me answer this
I don't carry keys
Because ii have some thuun print to get into the ok ay ah i guess i'm still living the darkages
Ii use a key of open to the oki'm sorry no subway card
Cause i used the phone
Yeah
How do you do that by the way because people were telling me not
But i don't want to like tie my transit card
To like my phoot it just just to alipay or hois it apple walit
Oh
You to do your phphone
Ah Ah
Because
Because i'm doing a purpose sel i like to have it separate okay
Right because you have money on your
On your transit ard
And if i have to to lose my phone
And i want
Want to be
Be to like get here
Ah
How often you lose your phone
No
Ah i don't know
Know
But just the case get okay
Okay
But yeah I
You like can i get away with just kind of going
Just having my phone on me
Yeah for months on end
Yeah Yeah
Ah i
You like i haven't carried cash in my wallet four about five six months now your way behind spend two years
But there you carry cash on one
I only use my wallet are you cash in teyou there's only two reasons
Why i have a wallet
One is at a habit
You know take group carry wolet
And two is just to kind of hold my credit cards and suffered that
Yeah
Right because it only i don't have any actual cash
And i want i have it for so ah it had cash all all for two years
Right so here's okay
So here's
This is what's interesting right so because 没有没有
I get it like when we go out
When we actually could leave the house in the morning
We're going to pink on for you know let's say ten twenty hours around going on a business trip
You want to be prepared
So you may bring other things right
But if i go out for a run
I know i'm going to come back home in a couple of hours
Right and so when i go out for a run
I just bring my phone
Yeah me too
And
嗯
I know that on that run
If i need something
I'll be able to go into any convenience or anywhere
And i'll be able to just use my phone
I'll be able to use ali pay apple wallet
Whatever it is
And get anything that i need
If i need it
So there's no sense of insecurity
Although i know that
If i go out through the day
I might bring my wallet with id in other types of things
But i think the truth
But that's the case
But we're talking about bare essentials right if we're essentials on the day
That they acthey have to have that because the other preferee stuff changes like if you're going to a meeting
You need to ing allowed right
But that's
That
But the running in the morning is that ltmmss test of very essensentitoo
It's ah 're 're phyouphphthat's right so rorolee lee
Guys remember royah
Yeah
Come come
So roy was just in town okay 's 's been out chchina
You know he lived here for quiwhile
While he know he til in
In the day
Ah he was here up until probably nine years ago
And he came back
And you know roy was like more china than anyone right i mean
You know guguy was deeply embedded in society
Here he's been living in an eself
He's gone a little softwright
So he comes back
We're at a restaurant
And he's like man
It's like really changed here right and and go
And we paid the bill and all of a sudden
We just used you know like contact with payment
We use our phones
I we pay
Whatever he literally looked at it
And he was like i sort of got i saw a farmer flash between my eyes
He decidecilike yeah
Like he decisaid alihe literally yeah like ererally like he went back to the nineteen fifth yeah
No ideideah no idea aa free em out 啊
It's tolly freaked him out
And he was like well and like there was like this sort of
Like level of this comfort
And was just kind like what you know i know
And there you go right
So things have changed
They changed them quickly
But sort of it's hard to keep up
Yeah
It is hard to keep in the states
I mean they have apple pay here appapple pay in states is not nearly as why leaves like literally everybody
It's stop every
Every vender but uis the phone
That thing thing know what that's right every matter how bigger literally every single one like i pay my utilties to the phone
I every single one
Every single thing you can pass me single phone buying movie tickets to your groceries to
To shopping at you know um
You know whatever stored by clothes
And it only takes like too clicks
So like it's the smart phone paradigm
Think it's a smart from paradom
Where you only have to do like one or two cooks
And it's a ubiquity eiit right like everything you do can be implemented in five seconds or us
And i think it's that's what's shocking
But how seamless and consistent everything it's not a one off
It's not like i can do this easeasbut everyeverything else is difficult
It is that everything can be done through every single intererage
Which is actually
When you really think about it is not easy
I mean it yeknow it's not just a technology
It's getting every place in china to adopt the same technoloadoption
Yeah Yeah
Actually when adotion so i think something about china
Like in terms of this mix of command and capitalism
That has allowed it to move faster
Because in some ways in china like people can they don't have an option
When we say this needs to happen
We want to build a road
Here it happens
So it's this perfect mix of like open minded
But then also like if can impimplement everything simultaneously
And i somebody can make that call
Where is like if you're in india
In the us
There's no one that how that could make singular call
Yeah
It's like
It's like it's a capitalism
But without a bureaucracy they have to go
Ah that's a great
I mean
I mean so everything like kind just get done
Like once it's
You know once it's once there's a mission to do it
It just just done
There's
There's very little red tape or this and that kind of holding the way
There's you know you
You unlike like debating over years to kind of like buila bridge or are highway
Where it's just get stuck
There
There like it just gets done
And i mean
And yeah
I mean it can be
It be
Be little daunting and scary in a way at times
But you know the growth and kind of success that we have the benefit of kind of um getting here is really in a large part due to the fact
That it's an authoritarian country
That's capitalist at all at the same time
He know same
And it's lucky says a very good combination of both what are the downsides
Where i feel
I feel like i mean people lisaying the even americamerica are in the west right i mean they hear
They don't hear us talk about this
And i'm pretty sure
They'll automatically think about the negatives right
Yeah
Like that that the the
The next censor right even about that like okay
So everyone's using alipain which chapic right we use that for subways for transportation
For buying a food from paying bills
Everything it's getting tracked right
The company
The government has access to it
Where's have no privacy or privacy is obvious that we chats going monmonitor is obvious all that stuff right
So that's going to be the western argument
But like for us we never talk about that kind of stubecause we don't really care right
Exactly what chat getting wondered
But you know know this podcast has never
Never going actually
Tually it on air ir spend all this time weve spent the last one hour on something that's never going to actually be heard by anyone
So but
But why
But here's my question having said that why do you not care
Well
Personally i think the whole kind of privacy issue is
Is not something that i really care about it
Because i don't
Don't really care
Because i don't really have anything to that i really wannhold ld i really care
If someone is watching like if my emails
You're someone looking at my emails
I'm going
Going know it just going to find normal kind of emails
Inthere here like not going onfiy adthing as if any value or incriminating to me in any
In any way
So it wouldn't afafct ct me any
Anyway
If someone was
If the government was looking at my
We chat or
Or look at my emails
It just it wouldn't affect you know when my biggest
My vishes
But you know my
My biggest fear is my biggest feis
That tomorrow jujun just disappears
And is locked up forever
But the only reason we don't care
As we don't see the implications
The actual monitoring of this is invisible
It's what actually happens
If you ah with one monitor ors only if something
Something going to happen to you
If you're doing something
That's
You know me that's naive
That's so naive
That's
That's not true
Because that's you're assuming that
That unless
You do something wrong
You won't get passes
So like there's like you have that assumption no not in every case
But i think that there are so many people if they are monitoring
There are so many people to monitor
That they don't have the resources to go after every single little thing that you need they're going to go after things are on a priority for them
Wherever they are right
They're going do things of priorty
So they're going to do their do diligence because
Because they have limited resources in terms of there re's so the frequent people right
So so if so mourdering everybody they're going to go after people that are actually making a case to be
To be monitor or cut
Because they have to direct and devote resources to do that
And you know that tomorrow they're going to around ound of the people that made podcast about this
Because you know well this will
This would be the true test wouldn't it so we know that
If this particularly say this particular appps geget shut down
Right then now this particular erpse so this all this whothing this same productions
Let's say this whole production get shut down
Then we know
But if it doesn't
Then we know it
I mean
So i'm
I'm wwilling to try
That's a nka whisky talking
But cheers
Cheers
Cheirers
You know
Because i know
I felt you know it could be coming from a partially nayou standpoint
But i just felt like i've been living here
And not i cannot recall a single instance living here
Where i felt ii had to like
Oh
I can't do that because on
On china
Oh I can't
I've ve lived here
Exactly how i would have lived back in the states
If not even
Even more free in a lot ways culturally speaking right
So i've never had any kind of intrusion on my lifestyle
That i felt like i was inhibited or have my hands tied
Or i had to be careful
Or i couldn't do something
Or
Or i was kind of you know oppressed sed anyway just by living my own life
I've
I've never felt in instance of that
And
And i'm not like a completely square person either and i mean
I know i am my sherifun
So i've never
I've never felt that here
Even though i know it's there
I'm not denying that it's there
I know it's there
But it's never had aa material impact on my life living here
That i've noticed anyway
This reminds me of joe ptleleowon and the mainshiicks
我喜欢我喜欢我是who's that
Whose joe the guy with the glasses and he's the guy that kind
Kind um turns on
On Oh
Enggerance is bliss
Yeah Yeah
Oh No
It's that ignorance ces this because ignorance is not knowing or denying that there
If you know he knoknows it there
He just wants ys say no
But he wants no
He wants it to be raaced from his mind
So he wouldn't know it's there here
Heheknow that conversations
Seeing that stake
He's like wash me clean
Put me back in the matrix
So that i don't know anything about the matrix
I don't know the matrix even exists because why he says ignorance ces list
Because he's
He's tortured by the fact
That he knows that the matrix is there
He's outside the matrix
He knows everything that's going on he's making the case i
He wants we put back
And the matrix have this sllight white clean
You know live like a very successful life with being completely abilious right
And he's refer into that
As he nerves this was well
We're refering to is
Oh
We know it's there
We know that matrix is there right
But it just hasn't really had it in actual impact on my life
I don't know
I can't speak for you that right right but for me
I've never felt restricted and anyway living here for ten years that's just me
You know the only thing
The only time i really felt that
Or i feel that is on internet
You know those internet is answered here right
So you know there's certain size
But do like stupid sites
Anyit's
It's not like it's really
Really Oh
Ii can't like dothing
And you know with vpn and we get around ound
Really
So this is a rid of vpn
And ah ah ah ah we have to move ct fair ararguis a fair perspective
Yeah
It's not a argum
And just it
This is my personal p
It's a fair perspective
I mean
And you know these things are
You know what happens now
What happens tomorrow
What happens in the future are all different things
You know so when you start looking at social credit ratings
And how you know like if you found a lot
There's cameras
Everywhere if you found a lot
You may be raii memean
I found lot
Lot right
I have my incidents on susubway
You get rated an angry person
And that affects your ability to access services across or a lot of different rounds
Right and so eventually
But what do you talking about though you
You
I think that's already happening
And already happening
So if you walk around the street
You
You found a lot
You do you walk around the streets
Every mooment
Every facial reaction is already being capped
Right i understand that how
That information then ultimately gets used to
Hey
Am i going to extend this person's visa
And i going to these are all things that are happening
But you don't think that's happening the west st the argument
And know we're not debating what's happening in the west right
We're talking about the
The
The sort of the uh
The ubiquity of these things that are happening
Here you know it's probably happening everywhere
But these are things
That i think that you know i'm not going to be joe pentally ownner ignorance ces
But i'm
I'm going to
To think about these things
You know
So i just have my visa renewed
I have
Have been a good citizen for last couple of years
You You
But you know
Let's ll see
Ll see
See all the things
Things
Youyou've experienced in china
I'm done in china
What are the moments in your life
Where you felt like kind
You felt what you're talking about in terms of you know you were endanger in any way or of of
It's like when these things happen
It's not like it's gradual
It's like it's
It's binary
It's like if you live in venezzuela
And you live in these kind of totalet i mean these regimes exist
It's binary doesn't
It's not like you know it's slow
It's gradual
It's one of the other right
And so i think that's what we're talking about
It's not like you know um certain people face it
So certain people don't face it right
But there are all the conditions present that that could en
And so so that's always in the back of your mind
I think that's absolutely true
Um yeah
That's a absolutely
And this is that in my personal lifestyle
It's never affected i felt at least noticeably in any way that i would have behaved anyway you
I mean that's me
And i can't speak for everyone
But some people may choose do with other things
But i've never had to come check my own behavior here because and know i elt i felt that when i think about
Even us right
When i think about
Ok Well
Let's say
How i wants to make a film about something
When i think about what's next in my future
I want to create a company
That that does i want
Want to help people side outside
Outside any time
These things conflict right
You immediately have a situation
Where two things are opposing each other
Where is in the western world
I think it's a much more subtle
And the level of things happening
And there's much more flexibility so unless
I'm directly opposing that you know the country's national interest here
I think it's much more subtle
Led how we could do
I'm sure
You've had to edit certain things
And even the stuff that you do
Now uni think censorship
Ps
A whole different topic
Yeah
Yeah
That's
That's
That's more
It's all think together
Because censorship
It's all about control
Right it's all about control
It's not
It's all the same thing
Whether it's like they want to control what i do here or here or here
It's all about control
So it
It takes on different forms
Different name
Censorship
What everyone to call it
It's all the purposes the same right the purposes the same so
So then it comes down to going back to what i just said i mean are you were willing
Ling cleyou know how do you feel about this especially living here um the biggest argument in the west is the freedom of
Of your own rights and privacy
And you know equality
Blah blablah right
But over here i mean this type of discussion has don't really happen
And you just kind of go with the flow
And just kind of live your life
And it's
It's almost like you it's not ignorant to it
It's just it's not for the general public that's not a priority
It's not a priority
Yeah Yeah
Which i find it fascinating
Because when i first moved here
I was the biggest
I was quite argumentative against people
And always always debating people about the way
They think the way they live
You know it's like how could you think this way or that way coming from the west
Is you know this is ritiiculous
How can acaccept the government being like this or censorship for that
And
But now i just said know no
I feel like living here for a while
Maybe
Maybe it's very much
Maybe i've been here for so long that i am
I have been affected by the chinese government
And i am a good citizen
And
And like we should view this as sort of one side the other
Because
Because it's
It's balanced right
So first of all we shouldn't naive about what is like to live here
And we shouldn't be naive about what is like to be at home
Right there's there shouldn't be any naither
There should be awareness
But the second thing is that
Where is your sensitivity to privacy may have decreased
I can say that in the work
In the work that i do um nine
Nine percent of our customers are from china
They're from here
And there sensititivity
Privacy es incincreasing is it
Oh
Absolutely you notice
You notice it from them like ii think so well we deal with
You know the volume of customers we were we work tort of a susumer business
The amount of customers we deal with
Is you know this is it's a lot
Right i mean it's a lot
So the even in the use of data
If you think about like everyone has photos
And has you know information and data and all this stuff and privacy is important
Not just in the context of the government
But do you want youare competitor knowing about your stuff
Do you want other people knowing about the relationships
You have
So i think there's certain things that we kind of frame in eespversu's west
And these ffalse sort of rarameks
You ah
Everyone cared like no one wants their personal photos like online period
So i think we look at things
And we kind of create these full sort of premises
The reality is that no like everyone's using data
Everyone's having their life captured
And no one wants their personal information put on the internet
And that's the bottom line right and so then
So then
When these this information is being collected for a different reason
But then somehow it's being compromised
These were things that we all worry about
So i think it's
It's It's
It's
It's out is actually just being really open
Underunderstanding sort of these
These issusues
That impact sort ort everywhere
And that in the moment you may not think these are important
It doesn't impact you
But at some point it will impact tive
And are the things
Where you didn't see it happening in minuit it all all sides
You know
I think 都是the things
Sap
不许浪费 我