Recorded in 2011, the self-titled album showcases some of the songs written by Plutoniates in their first three years as a band. Their sound is often said to be a blend of several different bands coupled with influences unique to themselves. In the past, they've been compared to the a blend between the Decemberists, Silversun Pickups, Avett Brothers, and Nirvana, with a slightly greater emphasis on the moodier or dark edge found in many Nirvana songs.